I thought that I should elaborate on my earlier somewhat cryptic reference to Clayton (Contra Costa County, California) as “spooky.”
For the last couple of years I’ve been paralyzed, in a state of shock at the sheer hubris, the awful ugliness of post 9-11 America. The country has suffered a paroxysm of jingoistic fervor and of vile nationalism that has served to obfuscate not only why the US was attacked, but the road out of its dilemma.
Suburban house, Pacifica, California
It is as if the vibrant dissent to the world’s biggest military apparatus prior to 9-11 was for naught. Forgotten was the ugly history of US foreign intervention, that Hussein of Iraq was merely one of an unseemly coterie that did the bidding of US corporate interests under veil of fighting “communists.” Even now, as evidenced by presidential candidate Barack Obama’s repudiation of his minister’s statement that the World Trade Center attacks were “chickens coming home to roost” (I prefer Chalmers Johnson’s term: blowback), the US polity has yet to fully come to grips with its culpability for 9-11. 9-11 was a fundamentally revolutionary act in nature, it was a repudiation of capitalism (that is, capitalism in its 20th century form: corporate-state militarism) and its adjunct, US military dominion. The US military had been cast by its supporters as the noble bulwark against “communism”, and though now the enemy has been magically transformed into “terrorism”, the true goal of such overwhelming military force remains global domination of resources. To wit: Iraq.
So I can’t help but pass through the seemingly bucolic landscapes of places like Clayton and not feel both the military cost of making them possible and the improbability of their future viability. And having some affection for the US Constitution of 1787, and for democracy in general, landscapes filled with security infrastructure, nationalistic icons, giant automobiles, and … well, dare I say? … copiously irrigated lawns … make me, to put it mildly, uneasy. (By using the phrase “security infrastructure”, I intend to refer broadly to the “gated community”, inward looking, profoundly anti-civic nature of Clayton and most suburban landscapes)
James Howard Kunstler is typically evocative of the American early 21st century zeitgeist in his recent description, which I’ll take the liberty of quoting at length:
Of course, one of the reasons that Americans are so anxious to get away on a holiday weekend from the places where they live is because we did such a perfect job the past fifty years turning our home-places into utterly unrewarding, graceless nowheres, where the private realm of the beige houses is saturated in monotony, and the public realm has been reduced to the berm between the WalMart and the strip mall. Now, we barely have the gasoline to run all this stuff, let alone escape from it for a weekend.
We’re at a dead end with all this and a lot of Americans are paralyzed with fear about what’s next. This may actually be a deeper fear than the anxiety about money and banking in 1933, when Franklin Roosevelt was sworn in and tried to reassure the nation. Back then, despite the grave problems of capital, we still had plenty of everything: plenty of good productive land, plenty of manpower earnestly eager for hard work, plenty of ore in the ground, shining cities equipped with excellent streetcar systems, a railroad network that was the envy of the world, sturdy small towns and small cities fully equipped with locally-owned business, and a vast number of small family farms that could re-absorb family members unable to get wages in the cities. Most of all, we had plenty of oil in the ground, and the world’s biggest industry for getting it out and selling it. What we didn’t have in 1933 was cash money.
The crisis at hand now goes way beyond a crisis of capital — though that is certainly part of it. Notice how many of the things we had in 1933 are gone now. Our cities, with a few exceptions, are imploded husks. Our small towns and small cities (Schenectady, home of G.E.!) are gutted, especially in terms of locally-owned business. Our passenger rail system is worse than anything a Soviet ministry might produce (while the airline industry that replaced it is dying of a kind of financial hemorrhagic fever). Our local transit hardly exists anymore. Family farms have all but disappeared.
This is why I find places like Clayton to be spooky. The very placidness of this landscape belies the violence which created it. Clayton is near to an ideal, fictive American landscape in its cartoon-like lush irrigation set amidst the parched, golden hills of the Coast Range. Nevertheless, it is, to me, a gravely flawed landscape.
I cringe at having to attempt to explain any of this to people who hang American flags on their privacy fences, and who have filled their carports with giant, gaudy gas guzzlers; but most of all, who have chosen, as evidenced by the landscape they’ve created for themselves, at some level reject civic life.